Tuesday, September 13, 2005

Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite

From the New York Times: March of the Conservatives: Penguin Film as Political Fodder

Apparently some people have decided that "March of the Penguins", a documentary about penguins, is not a scientific documentary but a Christian allegory and morality tale.

"That any one of these eggs survives is a remarkable feat--and, some might suppose, a strong case for intelligent design," Andrew Coffin wrote in the Christian publication World Magazine. "Penguins are really the ideal example of monogamy," according to Rich Lowry, the editor of National Review. (Did you watch the movie, Rich? Penguins do take one mate at a time, but only during each breeding season. They swap partners every year. Apparently the "ideal" form of monogamy is temporary.)

Penguines are badass, no question about it. If I ever compare you to a penguin, in any fashion, be assured it's a compliment. But the story of Antarctica's Emperor penguins seems to me not an argument for intelligent design, but a starting point in understanding the theory of Unintelligent Design.

First of all, penguins are birds. But not flying birds, like most of the others. Nor do they run, like ostriches and other flightless birds. No, penguins swim. They are swimming birds. Second, they live in Antarctica. Nothing else lives in Antarctica, except for the occasional bit of lichen. In order to eat, penguins must dive into the ocean for fish, dodging predatory leopard seals the whole way. In order to breed, penguins must travel 70 miles inland to find a sheltered area that won't melt away when the spring thaw arrives. This is where flying would really come in handy. Too bad, penguins. You have to walk--waddle, really--and when you get tired of that your only alternative is to flop on your bellies and propel yourself across the ice with your already sore feet.

But here's the kicker. Once the penguins have mated, the males and females take turns walking back and forth to the ocean to feed themselves and bring food back to their young. Since it's the dead of winter, more of the ocean has frozen over, extending the length of the trek. Eventually the young become self-sufficient, whereupon their parents promptly abandon them en masse to fend for themselves. Now that's a family unit worthy of imitation.

The whole process is just daft. No one with half a brain would have forced an animal to live on Antarctica. And even if there was someone reason for stranding a species on a frozen wasteland, you'd at least give them the ability to metabolize ice, right? A god who created penguins in their present form must be either a moron or a sadist. Almost certainly both.

2 Comments:

At 9:01 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Indeed, most flightless birds show how evolution can only work with what it has. Have you ever looked at a Kiwi? Its wings are beyond useless. The only reason it has wings is that its evolutionary ancestors had wings. There are countless cases of jury-rigging in evolution. See more here: http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/jury-rigged.html

 
At 12:31 PM, Blogger crystal said...

Indeed, I must share your disagreement with the Christian right. I read the article you included a link to - it was horrifying. Too bad they have to be uninformed AND self-righteously preachy - one on its own is bad enough. I must admit though, I find the slip-up on their part about the "ideal" form of monogamy that you pointed out to be HIGHLY amusing.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home