Sunday, November 27, 2005

Over Under Sideways Down

"When I was young people spoke of immorality;
But all the things they said were wrong are what I long to be."
--The Yardbirds

Let's get philosophical, shall we? A few weeks ago I sent my friend Jesi a link to a letter by scientist and ardent atheist Richard Dawkins to his daughter. It's titled Good and Bad Reasons for Believing. Essentially Dawkins outlines the scientific method for 10-year-olds and explains why religion is a silly thing. I asked Jesi, who considers herself a Christian but a very nontraditional one, to tell me what she thinks of it.

In the response she posted on her blog, Jesi wrote that she believes in God because wants to: "It is no more complicated than that. I want to believe that there is a God." In all my internal debates about whether God exists, never did I want God to exist. I sought merely for factual information that could prove or disprove God's existence. Desiring a deity is foreign to me.

So I'd like to broaden the discussion to any of you religious types who read here. Do you consider wanting God to exist a good reason to believe that God does exist? Would this world be a bleak/lonely/depressing place if you didn't believe in God? What lack do you experience in the world that God fills for you?

9 Comments:

At 2:12 PM, Blogger Jesi E. said...

::raises an eyebrow:: Well, for the enlightenment of your dear readers, I will state this much: The point of my blog is to show that believing that the nature of God can be measured and weighed through scientific method like plant could is ridiculous. He could absolutely exist in a way that is outside of human study (or, at least, current forms of human study). When evidence cannot be given to prove or disprove something, how do I make such a decision? That is when I determine I want to believe. There is reason behind why I want to believe that chance above the other is outline in my post.

Just thought I'd let you know I wrote a limited response under the comments, Zach.

 
At 6:31 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

If there is not a God, then what warped higher power set this mess up?

-K.

 
At 7:39 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Posted a comment on her blog. Seemed less socially appropriate, but more discussion appropriate.

 
At 3:58 PM, Blogger Robert Ludlow said...

In general, when I consider all the reasons people give for doing things, sometimes "Because I want to" seems the most reasonable. It certainly can be the most genuine response.

 
At 6:21 PM, Blogger Robert Ludlow said...

Addendum to my email: it troubles me not should I be wrong, but I guess that is because the manner I have built the universe in my mind does not include a case where I could, say, go to Hell for having the wrong ideas. Mostly, in my head, if there is a god it must exist somewhere along the lines of how I believe it, and if not, then there is no god, and I won't mind it because I'll be dead. That is, in addition to all that reason I ended up with at the end of the email. i am sorry it wasn't more coherent and concise. And I do hope you are not so bothered by having to read yet another lengthy response to what has already seemed to bring forth a prodigious amount of talk.

 
At 6:42 PM, Blogger Jesi E. said...

Zach, this is terribly off topic, but I figure this is as good a way as any to tell you about this: My former professor and dear friend of mine is having a poetry reading frontlining Catherine Wagner (have no idea who she is; she is from Idaho and England and apparently her work is "pretty radical, fractal, playful, collaged." More importantly, my professor will be reading some of his work (he has his PhD in Poetry). So, if you're looking for a good excuse to come to Norman, this might be a good time. Though, it's short notice. The reading will start Thursday at 7:00 p.m. at the Sam Noble blah blah blah museum. Hope you can come.

BTW, thanks, Rob, and may I suggest this: If you do go to hell for having the wrong ideas, then there is nothing to be done. You hope to live the right way. But I also hope that God is just. C.S. Lewis made a very bold statement in his book "The Last Battle." Essentially he stated that God would forgive those who sincerly tried to be good and serve the right God, but were deceived or confused for some reason. Absolutely fantastic book. I don't use this as an excuse not to try to find the truth, but just another reason for me to hope.

 
At 10:16 AM, Blogger Unknown said...

God kept me from getting robbed by gang of thugs in downtown San Diego last week.

 
At 10:56 PM, Blogger Jesi E. said...

Hm, Amber, I think your thoughts are interesting and I'm glad you posted them. I do not, however, find myself in agreement with your belief. If I lived my life and found that there was nothing else to it, I do not believe I would be dissappointed.

I saw a movie with my brother tonight. We went to "Hastings," the video/music/book store for those who are unfamiliar with it, and I bought him a very late birthday present before renting a couple of movies. We listened to the CDs, the birthday presents I bought him, on the way to the theater. Neither of us had heard this music before and it was great. The car we were driving in had a sunroof, so I leaned back and watched the moon and the stars are the way there. We purchased a marbled mocha macciato at Starbucks before heading to the theater. The movie we watched, "Capote," was inspired and beautifully done. We listened to the music on the way back and I spent the time of silence thinking about what I was going to post on my next blog. I am going to write about the last year of my life and the changes I have experienced. When I got onto the computer, I thought, "I haven't read Zach's blog in some time. I'll read that before I type up my thoughts." That leads me here.

Why does this matter? Because, if I died tonight, I would be extremely happy. I love life. I love living it every day without having any direct contact with the supernatural or any God. I live my life for the happiness it gives me. Everything I have right now is sufficient. In fact, it's beyond sufficient. It is amazing. I do not find the thought that this might be everything is depressing. In fact, it is the pleasure and satisfaction that I receive from my everyday experience that makes me long for something more. Every day I can think and experience somethng new, something different, something wonderful is a day that I want to live another day. And to believe that I might be able to continue this in some shape or form after I'm dead in a way that I cannot comprehend at this moment is something desirable. But if it does not happen, I must say that living up to this point and within the time and the experience limits I have been giving is not a sad thought for me. Actually, it is a comforting thought on its own.

 
At 9:54 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

It's so interesting to see how people arrive in such different places. It facinates me how different people really are. We both love life passionately, it seems, but I guess you're saying that, for you, being so happy with your life makes you content to leave it at that if there isn't anything else. You savor what you have and are grateful. And I'm saying I love life so much, I want more more more. I don't want it to end. I think about 80 years and it just doesn't seem like enough time. I want to go on and see what else there is, I want to come back here some day and do it all over again. To think maybe this is it....yes, that would definately be depressing for me. Such different mindsets, huh? Two totally different ways to look at exactly the same thing.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home